« Small Business Update 4/29/05 | Main | Court of Appeals Strikes Down the Broadcast Flag »

May 02, 2005

Blawg Review #4


Welcome to Law & Entrepreneurship News for Blawg Review #4. This blog is powered by law students at the University of Wisconsin Law School. Things have been a bit slow around here lately, as the students are immersed in final examinations, so we are thrilled to have the Blawg Review this week.

Let me begin with a question: Do a disproportionate number of blawgers use Blogger? Having recently hosted the Carnival of the Capitalists, I can tell you that those business folks have mostly hopped off the Blogger train. I suspect that lack of funds (law students) and lack of technical prowess (some of the rest) explains the difference, though I am just speculating.

Ok, I know you're anxious, so let's get to the posts ...

Law Schools

Jeremy Blachman, on the eve of his graduation from Harvard Law School, confesses the dirty little secret of all new law school graduates -- law school teaches you nothing about the law. Colin Samuels, ten years removed from law school, consoles Jeremy: "You know more than you think you know." and "Much of what you know is useless in the real world, but will be impossible to forget."

My co-blogger Christine Hurt at Conglomerate asks, "Are Law Schools Family Friendly?" So how about this for irony: in her post, Christine observes, "Outside of class time, I am available whenever a child ... has a dentist appointment...." Then, look what happened this morning!

Robert Ambrogi suggests that at least two law professors would not have made the Legal Affairs list of "Top 20 Legal Thinkers in America" had is not been for their famous blogs. Another, Larry Lessig, would have made the list without his blog, but not without the internet. (Did anyone else notice the heavy University of Chicago representation on this list?)

Arthur Andersen

The Dark Goddess of Replevin -- who wins the award for coolest blawg name -- has learned this from the Arthur Andersen and Enron prosecutions: shred early and often.

For those who are interested in the Arthur Andersen case before the Supreme Court, I have a short primer on the legal issues (albeit with a horrible prognostication about the Supreme Court ... criminal law isn't my thing) and an update on the oral argument, with thoughts on SOX.

Intellectual Property Law

Stephen Albainy-Jenei of Patent Baristas -- which would get my vote in any blawg design contest -- discusses the proposed Bioshield II bill in a post entitled "Bioshield Bill Would Provide Drug Patent Term Extension". That bill as originally drafted would have added a wild card provision that could add up to two years to the exclusive patent term for a drug. For a major drug, those two years could be worth billions of dollar in revenue. The draft language in the new bill has now been changed to require the winner of a contract to name the designated drug within 180 days of receiving the contract.

Bloggers have been noticing Wal-mart's efforts to stop online criticism, and Evan Brown of InternetCases.com describes a recent arbitration victory for Wal-mart in his post, "Wal-mart on the Domain Name War Path".

War Stuff

Publius at Ex Post offers another in a series of posts about the debate between John Yoo and Jeremy Waldron on torture. In Power of the Presidency, Marbury, and Torture, Publius wonders about the framework for the constitutionality of presidential action. Professor Yoo noted in the debate that there can be situations where Congress not only has failed to regulate, but could not regulate the President. This post, and the discussion in the comments is aimed at fleshing out this very important idea that has seen shorter shrift in the debate.

Last week seems to have been the week for things believed extinct to resurface. On Thursday, it was the Ivory-Billed Woodpecker, but two days earlier heralded a rare Supreme Court sighting of the Curtiss-Wright doctrine of presidential supremacy in foreign affairs.  As explained by Julian Ku at Opinio Juris, the Court's return  to the doctrine after two decades, in an opinion written by Justice Thomas, may indicate the depth of Court support for deference in foreign policy matters to the Executive Branch and may point to the Court's future direction in cases involving enforcement of international court judgements and conduct of military tribunals. (Thanks to Colin Samuels for submitting this post.)

The Centrist -- a UCLA law student who gets big kudos from me for having participated in the Whad'ya Know Quiz -- is writing on Jag Central about the death sentence handed out by a military panel against double murderer Army SGT Hasan Akbar. The Centrist is also an Army Captain, and he helpfully explains the next steps in Akbar's appeals process.


You can make of this heading what you will, but here are two posts about the California legislature, which seems to have a lot of time on its hands.

So Cal Lawyer describes efforts to ban "pay per view" hunting.

E. L. Eversman at AutoMuse provides an "Update on California Crash Parts Bill." Now, I will confess that I needed more than an update, because I had never heard of this bill, but this is interesting. According to E. L.,  "The Certified Aftermarket Parts Association and insurers seek to create an “affirmative action” program to force consumers to accept inferior imitation crash parts in their vehicles’ repairs rather than providing and paying for original equipment manufacture (Ford, GM, Toyota, etc.) parts." E.L. even finds a way to squeeze in the debate about Social Security!

Canon Law

Two entries here, neither about canon law per se, but both about things Catholic. (We could have had another post in this category had Steve Bainbridge submitted this week. See here and here and here and here, for example.)

In a guest post at Notes from the (Legal) Underground, Abnu (a former altar boy) describes the ancient doctrine known as "benefit of clergy" and its relation to the priest sex-abuse scandals. He concludes: "As long as the Church views sexual abuse of children by clergy as a moral failure, a breach of the vow of chastity, even a cardinal sin, it is a matter for confession, penitence, forgiveness and absolution."

Meanwhile, KipEsquire at Stitch in Haste follows up with this question: "Should the U.S. Indict the Pope?" Why not? The prosecutors of Martha Stewart and Arthur Andersen probably have some free time.

Speaking of abortion ... (I realize that we weren't speaking of abortion, but I couldn't find another more appropriate category for this post), Sean Sirrine at Objective Justice describes that Florida case in which the Florida Department of Children and Families is claiming that they have the authority to require a court to decide if a 13 year-old may have an abortion. According to Sean, a juvenile court that delayed the abortion and ordered a psychological evaluation will be overturned by the higher Florida courts.

Legal Research Services

Yes, we actually have two posts about legal research services, and in my book, that merits a separate category.

Nivine Zakhari at Tech Law Geek asks "How long before clients catch on to the fact that online legal research is supported by offshore resources that hardly charge the hourly rates many lawyers dream of collecting? Could this be what Tom DeLay found to be so 'incredibly outrageous'?"

Our friend Denise Howell at Bag and Baggage follows up on the story about Supreme Court justices doing their own internet research, linking to a story about HighBeam's gift of reasearch services to the high court. Denise wonders whether there are any ethical constraints on the acceptance of complimentary memberships by the judiciary.

Law Practice

Evan Schaeffer at Notes from the (Legal) Underground offers some advice to young lawyers, expressing his frustrations with underhanded litigation tactics and suggesting that the U.S. model of adversarial litigation should be "transformed from the ground up." Evan is so hot under the collar that contract murder is not out of the question. Here is my advice to Evan and his correspondent: become a transactional lawyer. Or better yet, a law professor. You will still have frustrations, but nothing that will drive you to murder.

I am embarrassed to admit that I had never heard of Law Day until reading David Giacalone's informative post at f/k/a. David not only teaches about the creation of Law Day by President Eisenhower, but offers some commentary on lawyers. Read the whole post, and get some haiku as a bonus.

Raffi Melkonian praises apprenticeship (not the Donald Trump way) over at Crescat Sententia: "If I was opening a restaurant, I'd go apprentice for five or six years in a classical french restaurant. A good lawyer ought to cut his or her teeth on the work of better lawyers for at least that amount of time."

The self-proclaimed Greatest American Lawyer -- who is formally anonymous, but gives plenty of tips as to his identity -- suggests that the "billable hour obsession" and unhappiness are joined at the hip, and "unhappiness is a function of lack of purpose.."

Carolyn Elefant blogs as  My Shingle, and last week she compared marketing by large firms (McMarketing) with marketing by small firms or solo lawyers. Here is the teaser: "It's pretty clear that law marketing has invaded large firm practice - and guess what?  They're all doing the same thing."

Anthony Cerminaro at BizzBangBuzz describes "How to Buy a Business in 10 [not so] Easy Steps."

Ron Friedmann at Prism Legal Consulting suggests that corporate counsel should use blogs as "legal radar."

Lawyers are famously mathphobic, but George at his eponymous blog is using some math skills he learned in grade school to debunk the EEOC's sexual harrassment statistics against Burger King. If you ask me, Burger King should be charged with "human harrassment" for that so-called food they sell, but that's another post.


Jeremy Richey offers a satire about tort reformers and plaintiff's law.

Dwayne at Law School tells the strange tale of a misdirected email and Reinder Eekhof's quest to rule the world. (Ok, I made that last part up)

Administrative Stuff

Thanks to Felix the Cat on Flickr for the original photo of the United States Supreme Court, a modification of which appears at the top of this post.

Blawg Review has information about next week's host, and instructions how to get your blawg posts reviewed in upcoming issues.

Posted by Gordon Smith at 10:18 AM in Around the Blogs | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Blawg Review #4:

» Belly Up to Blawg Review from Tech Law Advisor
Blawg Review #4 is up at Law & Entrepeneurship News. Related: Submission Guidelines available for all those who want to get in on the action next week at Conglomerate where... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2005 12:29:03 PM

» Gates on IP, Outsourcing from Tech Law Geek
This post featured in Blawg Review #4, hosted by Law & Entrepreneurship News. Take a look at what else they have! [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2005 12:42:22 PM

» Law & Entrepeneurship News Hosts Blawg Review #4 from Patent Baristas
The next edition of Blawg Review is up at Law & Entrepreneurship News. Law & Entrepreneurship News is a collaborative project involving Professor Gordon Smith and students at the University of Wisconsin Law School. Law & Entrepreneurship News provides ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2005 2:15:47 PM

» Carnival of the Capitalists from Accidental Verbosity

The May 2 edition of Carnival of the Capitalists is up, hosted at Incite. Looks like there's some fine links in a good format, so head on over for a blast of economics and business fun. Also up today and every Monday is the 4th edition of a new... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2005 4:24:27 PM

» Blawg Review #4 Available from PHOSITA ::: an intellectual property weblawg
Wanna have an inside track on the coolest law related blogging going on in the blawg-o-sphere?  Look no further than Blawg Review #4. Pour yourself a big glass of coffee and get ready to spend some time reading.  ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2005 5:01:13 PM

» EEOC v. Burger King operator from Overlawyered
The agency insisted there was a "pattern and practice" of sexual harassment at a company that owned 350 Burger King restaurants in 13 states, but the judge was not impressed with the agency's statistics, and... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2005 10:41:57 PM

» and the prize for coolest blawg name goes to... from the dark goddess of replevin speaks
me. Again (see footnote 36). As another edition of Blawg Review succumbs to my literary charms. That and--what is it now? Two dollars?--will get me a ride on the subway in New York. [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2005 1:05:45 PM

» Blawg Review #4 from Objective Justice
All of you law students wasting your time preparing for finals, its time to check out the next series of Blawg Review. Blawg Review #4 is being hosted over at Law & Entrepreneurship News and is as full of yummy law blogging as the past three reviews. G... [Read More]

Tracked on Jun 21, 2005 5:30:06 AM

» Law & Entrepeneurship News Hosts Blawg Review #4 from Patent Baristas
The next edition of Blawg Review is up at Law & Entrepreneurship News. Law & Entrepreneurship News is a collaborative project involving Professor Gordon Smith and students at the University of Wisconsin Law School. Law & Entrepreneurship News provides ... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 5, 2005 10:13:30 AM

» poker 656 from poker 656
poker 656 [Read More]

Tracked on Dec 9, 2005 6:02:03 PM

» MP3 download, Music CD, Online music from Digital Sheet Music Downloads from Supermusiconline.info
Download the sheet music for your current favorites and explore our ... Download sheet music for Grammy®-winning and related titles, composers, and artists... [Read More]

Tracked on Mar 8, 2006 5:20:40 PM

» Leather Furniture Search from Portal espaol de fabricantes de mobiliario
International search for construction industry manufacturers, associations and suppliers... [Read More]

Tracked on Apr 11, 2006 9:50:59 AM

» Shop Clothing, Apparel Brands, Shoes & Accessories from clothing, shoes and accessories items
Advanced Search · All_Laptops · Shopping > Clothing, Accessories & Shoes ... Sign in to find the best total price for Clothing, Accessories & Shoes [Read More]

Tracked on Apr 14, 2006 1:26:33 PM

» The Morning News - The Top 10 Albums of 2006 from Top 10 albums
After hundreds of albums and thousands of hours of listening to music, Andrew Womack narrows it all down to his top 10 albums of 2006. ... [Read More]

Tracked on Apr 25, 2006 4:49:26 PM

» 5 Lawmakers Arrested In Darfur Protest from Darfur. Separately,
were arrested at the Sudanese Embassy in protest of the Sudanese government's role in atrocities in Darfur. Separately, a U.N. agency announced a drastic [Read More]

Tracked on May 1, 2006 8:08:55 AM